Behold the Man

Jesus’ trial before Pilate consists of seven scenes. They follow a familiar pattern.

Peter Leithart writes,

The Fourth Gospel is a series of trial scenes, full of courtroom language like “witness,” “judge,” and “judgment.” Jesus usually stands in the dock as the accused. He performs a miracle, or says something, and the Jews crowd around to accuse, just like their father, the Accuser (John 8:44).
Fittingly, John’s Gospel climaxes with a long account of Jesus’ arrest, trial, crucifixion, burial, and resurrection (John 18-21).
…the trial before Pilate (John 18:28-19:15) is divided into seven scenes, each scene change marked by Pilate’s movement in and out of the Praetorium (John 18:28, 33, 38; John 19:1, 4, 8-9, 12). Outside, Pilate talks to the Jews; inside, he talks to Jesus… Does the seven-scene trial follow the days of creation? Not impossible, since there are other creation-day sequences in John (Prologue; John 1-2). Try it on:
Day 1: Court meets early in the morning (John 18:28)
Day 2: Jesus is King
Day 3: Barabbas or Jesus
Day 4: Coronation (John 19:1-3)
Day 5: Behold the Man
Day 6: Son of God
Day 7: We have no king but Caesar (John 19:12-15)
[The sequence] appears to work best at the beginning, middle, and end: Court begins as light breaks; Jesus’ mock coronation on Day 4, when heavenly lights “rule” the day; while Jesus is presented as King and (perhaps) sits enthroned before the Jews, they pledge loyalty to Caesar, an anti-Sabbath. The inverted Sabbath (Day 7) is stronger when we catch the echoes of the temple dedication in John 19:13 (cf. 2 Chronicles 7:3): When Yahweh takes His throne, Israel bows to the pavement; but when King Yahweh is presented in the flesh, the Jews turn to Caesar.

The bookends and the central pivot are clear, but what about the steps in between? If we take some of the other threads of the Bible Matrix cord into account, the typological significance of these extra steps is made apparent. The dramatic sequence draws upon the sevenfold covenant pattern, the annual harvest feast pattern from Leviticus 23, the Creation/Tabernacle pattern, and the legal sequence of sacrifice that begins with Initiation and ends with Representation. We can also tack on the Heptateuch to round things out.

TRANSCENDENCE
Day 1 (John 18:28-32)
The court meets as dawn breaks.
“Judge Him by your own law.”
(Sabbath – Initiation – Ark of the Testimony – Genesis)
HIERARCHY
Day 2 (John 18:33-38)
Jesus’ is revealed as the royal heir.
“For this purpose I was born…”
(Passover – Delegation – Veil – Exodus)
ETHICS: Priesthood
Day 3 (John 18:38-40)
Barabbas and Jesus are offered.
“I find no guilt in him.” “Not this man, but Barabbas!”
(Firstfruits – Presentation – Altar & Table – Leviticus)
ETHICS: Kingdom
Day 4 (John 19:1-3)
The mock coronation of Christ.
“Hail, King of the Jews!”
(Pentecost – Purification – Lampstand – Numbers)
ETHICS: Prophecy
Day 5 (John 19:4-7)
The Law of Moses invoked by the Jews.
“I find no guilt in him.” “Behold the man!” “I find no guilt in him.”
(Trumpets – Transformation – Incense – Deuteronomy)
OATH/SANCTIONS
Day 6 (John 19:8-11)
The Son speaks; the curse of the Law upon the Jews.
“You would have no authority over me…”
(Atonement – Vindication – Laver & Mediators – Joshua)
SUCCESSION (Gentile worshipers)
Day 7 (John 19:12-15)
The Jews threaten Pilate. Jesus is condemned to death.
“We have no king but Caesar!”
(Booths – Representation – Shekinah – Judges)
.

As usual, just like the text itself, a chart like this is to be meditated upon. But I will make a few more observations.

  1. Coming from the high priest’s house to make their accusations, the Jews are actual “satans,” snakes in the Garden.
  2. Jesus as the promised Seed, the true firstborn, in the Exodus step accords with “that He gave His only Son” in the Exodus step of John 3:16.
  3. Barabbas means “son of the father.” The choice was between the true, blameless heir and the older natural heir who was a man of blood. This is thus a reprise of the choice between hairy Esau, the natural man (the goat) and smooth Jacob, the spiritual man (the sheep). Both animals were acceptable for sacrifice at Passover (Exodus 12:5), but only a lamb was acceptable as a Firstfruits offering.1For more on this theme, see The Meaning of the Sheep and the Goats, “The Arms of Jacob”. The Jews were tasked with choosing “a son of the herd or the flock” (Leviticus 1). They made a sinful choice, and yet they did choose the Son without blemish—for sacrifice.
  4. As Leithart notes, although Jesus’ claim to kingship is mocked, He is in total control of the proceedings. It is His accusers and murderers who are on trial. This is the wisdom, the judicial cunning, of Greater Solomon at play.2 For more on this theme, see The Meaning of the Sheep and the Goats, “The Ministry of Provocation.”
  5. “Deutero-nomos” means “second law,” and Deuteronomy is Moses’ repeating of the Law for a new generation of Israel. The idea at this step is the testimony of a minimum of two witnesses. This explains John’s record of Pilate stating twice, “I find no guilt in him” as the second bookend of the threefold Ethics step. The statement is found in the steps that correspond to the Bronze Altar and the Incense Altar, that is, the flesh and the smoke, with the holy fire of the Lampstand between them. As the Prophecy step, it also relates to the murder of the prophets after their legal witness, such as the martyrs/witnesses under the altar in the fifth seal in Revelation. Here it is Jesus whose blood will be splashed against the altar like the raging sea against the land.
  6. Unlike Adam, “the Man” here makes no defence of Himself. Instead, He is both the sacrifice and the judge.
  7. Booths brings us to the gathering of the Gentiles for worship. The irony here is as palpable as Jesus’ gathering of the Romans against Jerusalem at the Booths step of the complete first-century pattern.

Further reading:
The Shape of John’s Gospel
The Sevenfold Dream

Become a patron at Patreon!

You may like